And no I dont have a dial indicator.
Don't put it back together without one. The gears are worn, and the backlash has changed from when it was originally setup. You'll never know what it was now. At least with an indicator, you'll be able to set it to the top end of the "new gear setup" spec and be close.
There's a reason people pay other people to set up gearsets. Don't be a dumbass.