Gonna be a dog.
You are running a 27" tire.
I'm 4wd and running a 29" tire (235/75/15).
I was happily impressed with how much peppier mine accelerates with those. Yours must run like a scalded dog. I hardly ever use 1st gear to pull out with these smaller tires (stock 245/75/16's were heavier and 30.4" tall). My effective ratio is 4.33.
You might be happier with 3.73s and they are very common. Personally, since you already have 15" wheels, I'd recommend a taller tire.
FWIW, I get ~340 miles to a tank. I usually end up putting 18 gallons in it when I fill up. I can get more miles out of it if I baby it, but most of my driving is city/rural, literally 35-50 mph most of the time. There's always quite a distance back to the following car if I am first leaving a light. I run 2nd gear up to over 4300 rpm and drop it into 5th and decelerate to the speed limit + 6 or 7.
How are you going to deal with the speedometer error?
http://www.dakota-truck.net/TIRECALC/tirecalc.html is a pretty good calculator.
Run some numbers if you are deadset on keeping that size tire and changing the rear ratio. Ford put 4.10s in there for a good reason.
What was your original stock size tire?