So I just did my long stint from Oklahoma City to Atlanta.
Distances throughout testing was based on GPS, odometer readings varied from 0% variance to 3.5%.
First 200 miles I averaged 20 mpg @ 65 mph (minimal downshifting, steep grades only)
Second 200 miles got me 16 mpg @ 75 mph (minor grade caused downshift)
I slowed back down to 65 for the rest of the trip.
Before the trip my city/highway (70%/30%) fuel economy was about 19 mpg.
Here is my summary:
With 235/65-15 highway tires, and 265/70-15 highway tires, my 4.0L auto Ranger was capable of 25 to 26 mpg @ 65 mph. After moving to all terrain treads the Ranger is now only capable of 20 mpg @65 mph.
My next step is to change to a 4.10 differential and retest.
I believe the 4.10 will increase the driveline torque to overcome the added drag from the all terrain tire's softness therefore reducing downshifting to that similar to the smaller tires with highway tread. I expect only a 2 to 3 mpg increase. Not sure if all the mpg loss is from the soft tread or lack of power with the decreased torque of the taller tire.
I am lead to believe that a highway tire, even at 31" would have minimal negative affect on the mpg achieved. But who wants tall ass highway tires?
