I've always used an insurance agent that shops around for me.
Agents earn a commission. If you go directly, you might save a couple bucks.
I just changed to Kin.
When they run the standard form 5 homeowners insurance (They all use form 5), possessions are a percentage of the house value. They’re also a big part of the premium. Even if you have replacement insurance, if you have a loss, they first pay the depreciated value. Then when you actually replace the item, they pay you the difference. If I lost it tomorrow, I wouldn’t go buy furniture at Macy’s, I’d go to Goodwill and buy some quality wood pieces and do a little refinishing. My point is, think about what you have, and look at the insured amount of the possessions, and maybe reduce that number. It made a big difference in mine.
The tax appraisal is usually lower than the actual sales appraisal. The insurance company uses the sales appraisal estimate. The insurance companies only have to insure the physical house, not the piece of land. The insurance amount should be what it cost to rebuild the house. Now, having said that, I had that when I got hit by the tornado, and what you don’t consider, is that you have to do 20 or $30,000 of demolition before you can rebuild. The rebuild cost on my house is probably 300 K, and the land is twice that. The garage is just a plywood box on two by fours, no finishing on the inside, probably 30 or 40 to rebuild it with a contractor. So I haggled with them a little bit, and I got the rebuild cost down. But you don’t want to squeeze too hard on that one. You can live without a couple extra pieces of furniture, but you can’t rebuild the house without the doors and the windows, roof and staircase…
And if by chance it ever catches on fire, and you can’t put it out in a minute, go to the best restaurant in town and have a seven course meal and think about whether you should call the police first or the fire department first, and once you decide, call them. I’ve dealt with a couple of half burned down investment properties, and it’s the worst nightmare…
Hope it helps