Almost the same mpg? My buddy's GMC Terrain gets 30 mpg. Name one "real SUV" that comes close to that.
They can't, because the newer SUVs are heavier than the original SUVs that they replaced, and the automakers give them ancient, inefficient powertrains like the 4.0 V6, which is admittedly reliable but guzzles gas.
Crossovers are more than capable to do everything that 99.6% of SUV buyers want to do with them. Which is NOT OFF-ROADING!!! My Explorer is pretty off-road capable. Do I ever take it off-road? No. Never. Same as everyone else in this country. Do I wish it got better than 17 mpg and had a more comfy ride (like say, an Escape or a Terrain?) Absolutely. Same as everyone else in this country.
Everyone else? Hardly. I couldn't care less about ride. Fuel economy, I'll get to in a second.
Hence the shift away from truck-based SUVs towards crossovers. They ARE way, way WAY more practical for what 99% of everyone uses them for.
Yes, and a station wagon would be even more practical. If you want a comfy carlike ride, why not buy a better-handling, more fuel efficient station wagon? Is that SUV "look" really so important?
Crossovers, I say again, are silly. They are built to look like SUVs. That is all they do that they can do better than a wagon or minivan. Wagons can handle better in on-road situations, minivans would have more room.
You can have your crossovers, my mother has an Escape and she loves it. But I'm 21 years old, I don't care about ride, and the only reason I truly care about fuel economy is because I don't like to use natural resources with reckless abandon. If it weren't for that I'd get an Explorer or old-school Cherokee, no question.
The new Explorers, in my humble opinion, have lost their way. They're too heavy, not for safety in crash tests but for increased room, and they have nothing in particular that separates them from station wagons and minivans. The new Explorer only increases that similarity. It's exactly the same as a Flex or Edge. I ask you, is the "look" really important enough to choose the unibody Explorer over the Edge? Or any "crossover" versus its wagon competition for that matter?