• Welcome Visitor! Please take a few seconds and Register for our forum. Even if you don't want to post, you can still 'Like' and react to posts.

why all "water car/hydrogen generators" are scams


superdave, perhaps I can give you the results your looking for. My uncle has this very system of sending an electrical current through roughly 1/2 - 3/4 of a gallon of water for his 1999 v8 f-150. First off I will be very direct and tell everyone his overall gas mileage did infact double! so right off the bat it can be said it did work BUT not without a little bit of thinking power and they all can be addressed right in the very questions you asked dave.

#1 I think its pretty clear to the answer of this question. Yes an electrical current run through water will split the molecules, basic chemistry proves this even. BUT for this process to be useful enough you need a catalyst; a proper amount of baking soda works just fine.

#2, 3, and 4 Yes the computer will read the altered amount of fuel/air ratio and adjust the fuel level. BUT because of the O2 senser in the exhaust pipe located near/on the catalytic converter it will read it as a HIGHER level of air because the hydrogen burns relatively completely to the point that the senser will not recognize it. THIS communicates to the computer that because there is more air then is allowed for it adds fuel, because it thinks your burning lean. Now your not necessarily burning lean, it just believes that because of the added oxygen from the extra being taken in from the water molecule split. This is an easy fix however, all that is needed is a simple spacer for the O2 sensor. This simply spaces the sensor away from the pipe just enough. This actually allows the sensor to actually do its job better because it only reads the level of heat in the burn. After these measures are taken though the computer will then read it as needing to adjust the fuel level to a more lean mixture because of the added hydrogen. Because you are using 2 parts oxygen/1 part gasoline/1 part hydrogen it will then use half the fuel as opposed to 1 part air/1 part gasoline.

Now a second thing to watch out for is that you are holding enough water in the storage tank. As I cannot state a specific amount needed for every car or engine out there I can say specifically how much was needed for my uncle's 5.4 v8. He had very simply, a 3inch pvc pipe cut to about a foot in length with caps on either end, with cleanouts REFILLED WEEKLY (yes you cannot just leave it alone).

Finally make sure to check your fuse size as it compares to your energy level in the regulator used. It seems pretty simple but an unequal fuse will bust. Ex. a 20 amp fuse with a 30 amp regulator.

The problem most people have with these hydrogen fuel "generators" if you will, is that one, they do not allow for enough of a volume, two they fail to use a catalyst, it can be done without one but no significant gains will be noticed due to the fact that if the chemical process is done without a catalyst then it will prolong itself naturally of course, third they fail to refill it..very common problem, don't ask me why they don't think of this though..they notice the gains for about a week and then nothing..cmon people think about it here. Hope this helps:)

OH and btw, he even noticed some picked up power;)..can't say exactly though where it came from..(sarcasm, he never modified his engine except for this hydrogen cell)
 
Last edited:
No, it didn't.

um..excuse me buddy but yes it did. he and I both did the calculations about 5 times each going back to 3 months before he had it and 3 months after. so go ahead, tell me it didn't after I've seen the results first hand.:annoyed:
 
No. The energy from burning the hydrogen is EXACTLY (well, a little less) than the energy taken off the crankshaft to make it.

So burning hydrogen creates less power than it takes to generate 2 amps of electric current? I understand confirmation bias. Simple psychology.
 
first of all there's no additional energy required from the crankshaft to send the electrical current through the water. Yes you could say the crank spins the pulley that works the alternator that recharges the battery that sends the power to the regulator that powers the generator. But seriously, all the alternator does is keep the battery charged after the initial startup. And actually most of the energy made by the alternator is in truth wasted because its making more power then it uses. Secondly if you use a catalyst (again, baking soda) this isn't even halfway an issue.
 
I have a HHO Generator on a 1994 Ford Ranger With 31x10.50 Tires its a 5 speed 4x4 and Extended Cab. I took a road trip aproximatly 100 miles (can't remember the exact mileage) i tried keeping my foot out of it it was 75% interstate driving. I Filled up before i left (completely) then i filled up when i got back and divided my mileage by the EXACT gallons. I got 18 point some odd miles to the gallons.. The truck as 172,000 miles on it. With the tires being larger and the speedo not corrected i might have got 19 something to the gallon. Thats pretty believeable huh?????
I then installed an HHO generator pulling a max of 21 and some odd amps. Haven't bothered seeing how much output (litres/minute). I take another road trip 75% Interstate driving. I fill up COMPLETELY before i leave i drive there i drive back and once again i drove it easy but not what you would call trying to hyper mile (shuting your car off when coming upon an intersection or down a hill) I would accelerate slowly and not drive 75mph JUST LIKE THE OTHER TRIP. When i got back i had driven 75 miles and it took not even 3.1 gallons to fill it up. Just barely over 3 gallons. You tell me the mileage. Some may not know. Thats 25 mpg and maybe just maybe 26 with the uncorrected speedo.
You can't deny facts and I COULD CARE LESS if anyone believes me but i know what i am getting out of my truck now with the HHO generator. Driving to work and back with lots of city driving i am getting 22 to 23 mpg. With occasional hot rodding.
Another FACT. I tried climbing a steep hill in 5th gear at 40 mph (sharp curve at the bottom and can't come out of the curve fast) I bogged out in 5th and had to go to 4th. One week later same temp and no weather diffrences i hit the same hill at the same speed but this time i had my HHO generator installed and i lost 2mph in 5th gear and never had to go to 4th. So i am not a rocket scientist but that tells me that the HHO is putting out more power than the alternator is consuming powering the contraption. I know there is someone gonna say its a lie so once again I COULD CARE LESS IF YOU BELIEVE ME :nopityA:.
I know what i know and i can't deny the facts that i see and continue to see.

This is pretty bogus, and why no one should believe people who put this junk on their cars. Your original drive was for 75 miles, and you claimed "I got 18 point some odd miles to the gallons."

Exactly how much gas did you use? The math would suggest that number to be 3.9 "some odd" gallons. Hardly a precise measurement.

You then claim that on your 2nd run, with your Brown's Gas generator in operation, that you it took "3.1 gallons", and that you gained power.

Well, sloppy math aside, there is a clear reason why you may have gotten better mileage, and that is that you created a vacuum leak, which caused you to run leaner, and make more power.

Now before everyone goes out and unhooks a vacuum hose to save some gas, think about the long-term effect on your engine.

This is not the first whiz bang contraption to come along and suck up a lot of people's money, and it wont be the last.

No matter how hard you want to believe, if it aint so, it aint so.

-zz
 
if by electrolysis you mean the electrical current sent through the water that is used to seperate the hydrogen from the oxygen that would come from the regulator that is connected to a power source obviously (switch optional) that is then wired to a special fuse then is wired all the way to the generator itself inside the enclosure. Obviously though the initial source of the power would be the same as every other electrical piece in the vehicle, the battery, being recharged by the alternator.
 
This is pretty bogus, and why no one should believe people who put this junk on their cars.

ok I will admit that some things this guy said were vague and possibly a little biased (no offense) BUT your statement is downright stupid and uneducated. You basically called not just him an idiot but also everyone else who has ever done this sort of thing INCLUDING the ones who had good results with it stupid, idiotic, and untrustworthy. Just because it may not have worked for you does not necessarily mean 1 that you did everything right and 2 that everyone else is wrong.
 
if by electrolysis you mean the electrical current sent through the water that is used to seperate the hydrogen from the oxygen that would come from the regulator that is connected to a power source obviously (switch optional) that is then wired to a special fuse then is wired all the way to the generator itself inside the enclosure. Obviously though the initial source of the power would be the same as every other electrical piece in the vehicle, the battery, being recharged by the alternator.

I'm calling you out here. This is total crap, and you can't prove any of it. You clearly don't even understand how an O2 sensor works, or that it takes energy to make energy. Do you really think you get free energy from ann alternator?

MAKG and Evan have both presented correct information that is verifiable and based on science. The guys who are attacking them need to get a clue. I can't imagine why either of these guys would waste another minute talking to you guys.

Go spend your money, and when you're getting 50 mpg from your Ranger because you put a water bottle on it, then you can laugh at us ignorant egg heads.

-zz
 
ok I will admit that some things this guy said were vague and possibly a little biased (no offense) BUT your statement is downright stupid and uneducated. You basically called not just him an idiot but also everyone else who has ever done this sort of thing INCLUDING the ones who had good results with it stupid, idiotic, and untrustworthy. Just because it may not have worked for you does not necessarily mean 1 that you did everything right and 2 that everyone else is wrong.

Yaeh, if you do this, then you're an idiot. Can I be any more plain?

Bring your vehicle down here, and I'll test it. If it works, I'll kiss your ass and send the video to TRS.

-zz
 
You clearly don't even understand how an O2 sensor works, or that it takes energy to make energy. Do you really think you get free energy from ann alternator?

Go spend your money, and when you're getting 50 mpg from your Ranger because you put a water bottle on it, then you can laugh at us ignorant egg heads.

Fine you call me out I'll call you out, do you? an o2 sensor does exactly what its called. it reads whats in the exhaust gases and reports back to the computer so it knows exactly how much gas the engine needs. And no I never said you get free energy from an alternator, it takes force for it to run but that is force is taken from the designed use of the engine. so either way you might as well use the energy you get. Second of all your whole argument is based on a false idea, you called it a water bottle just cuz its based in water. You clearly do not understand the chemical process behind this. Hydrogen is a definite source of power, how do you think an actual hydrogen vehicle was made by honda, or that the trains work that use hydrogen as a fuel? Get off your biased opinions and pay attention to some proper results, not just your failed pathetic attempts to make the same thing that works for others.

Another thing..you quoted the entirely wrong statement for your most recent argument..
 
Last edited:
and yea, you can call yourself an idiot for being an ignorant egghead. The only thing I would bring to you if I had the time I would build one of these for you for free and build it up right. First of all you can't just put water in a contraption and snap a battery to it for it to work, you have to make sure the electrical current is not shorting out. Second of all this is the very root of your problem, you feel that YOU should test it. Why should I let you drive my truck. There are several examples out there that disprove your argument that you are simply too unwilling and ignorant to even acknowledge, noone needs to prove anything to YOU.

I would however be willing to tell you the exact amounts of fuel used and miles driven under the tests that my uncle and I performed (even though I doubt you will be interested and/or willing to hear them)

and as for not being able to prove it..I can pretty much prove it. If you follow the things I said and have half a brain it would work..although..maybe thats the problem.
 
Last edited:
Beef

Yes it works! Ignore the closed minded people.
Tom Antil
Fitchburg,Ma
 
ok I will admit that some things this guy said were vague and possibly a little biased (no offense) BUT your statement is downright stupid and uneducated. You basically called not just him an idiot but also everyone else who has ever done this sort of thing INCLUDING the ones who had good results with it stupid, idiotic, and untrustworthy. Just because it may not have worked for you does not necessarily mean 1 that you did everything right and 2 that everyone else is wrong.


This system violates BASIC laws of Physics! Anybody who's passed high school Physics should be able to see that it is totally impossible!

You're taking a molecule, splitting it apart, and recombining it. Where does your net energy come from? If you're really getting any, the world's energy problems have just been solved forever.

There are lots of things that you don't need to try in order to know that they won't work, like my perpetual-motion go-cart I envisioned when I was 5 years old. You can apply basic scientific laws and principals to a design in order to determine the outcome.

This is honestly the kind of idea I would expect a 5-year old to come up with and defend. You should be ashamed of yourself.
 

Sponsored Ad


Sponsored Ad

TRS Events

Member & Vendor Upgrades

For a small yearly donation, you can support this forum and receive a 'Supporting Member' banner, or become a 'Supporting Vendor' and promote your products here. Click the banner to find out how.

Latest posts

Recently Featured

Want to see your truck here? Share your photos and details in the forum.

Ranger Adventure Video

TRS Merchandise

Follow TRS On Instagram

TRS Sponsors


Sponsored Ad


Sponsored Ad


Amazon Deals

Sponsored Ad

Back
Top