Right now at 70mph I am running about 3100 rpm, The calculator I was using claims a 3.08 will drop me to 2500 rpm, makes me think 600 rpm less will get me better mileage. I hope I am right with how much people want for these rears.
Actually yeah, that isn't bad at all. Some people have these thoughts (drug induced delusions) of running a 4 banger like a big V8, 1,500-1,800 rpm, and it doesn't really work out for them.
2,500 RPM is pretty good, you just might see some better mileage out of that. If you were towing a lot the higher RPM would be better.
for the rest of you, Non-overdrive transmissions generally have a much deeper starting gear (or at the least somewhat deeper). And without that extra cruising gear, you kinda just have to deal with the occasional shaky start depending on the load. And he's already said he can start in 2nd gear. It doesn't sound like he's running a particularly large tire either.
3.08 would be a good ratio
for his application.
Just like how I'm going all the way to 4.56 with my 29" tall tires. Most would say I'm nuts for going that deep. However, my 5th gear is almost un-useable, basically 5th gear would now be equivalent to fourth gear and I get a bonus of easier starts.
It all depends on the application.