Ok, so I'll update this at the request of 85_Ranger4x4.
My ultimate finding was that the plugs were wrong. The left hand head is part of the cluster body and cannot be removed for individual replacement. Also, the plug cavities in the body were different between the two. The pinouts were all sorts of wrong and the plug bodies were barely even the same shape, it wasn't even possible to jam the plug into the hole.
Given that I already wanted to take my dash out to clean and the 1st gen dash is not at all hard to remove I installed the dash harness from my donor truck as well as the instrument cluster after swapping my speedo head (I don't like the 88MY font on the odometer and that odometer actually pretty closely represents the real mileage on the engine I installed), and it works perfectly.
Unfortunately it looks like the swap is not plug and play, it would seem from what I found that you need the cluster and the harness. I didn't dig into possibly re-wiring the harness at all though. I also am not sure that it isn't a model year change since my donor truck was an 88 and the one I was putting parts on was an 87.
That's sad to hear

I really wanted the look of the stock tach, but i dont want to swap the harnesses over. Thanks for looking into it
