You may have had a bad starter relay(on the fender) and then mis-wired it after replacing it.
Starter relay(some call it a solenoid) has two larger posts
One larger post will have 1 wire only, that wire/cable goes to the starter motor, this needs to be the only wire on that post.
The other larger post will have several wires/cables, Battery's "+" cable is here, alternator wire(s), power distribution wires, ect....
There will be one or two smaller posts on the relay, one will have an "S" near it, that is the post that will connect to the Ignition switch(key), when this post has 12volts(key turned to START) relay will close and pass battery power to starter motor.
2nd smaller post, if there is one, will have an "I", it is usually not used any more, it was used to give the Coil extra power when starting the engine cold, it would have a wire connected directly to Coil's "+" terminal.