Looking at an '09 - what to watch out for?

[ThermionicEmissions]

What...have I done?

 

[Shran]

Between those two trucks and knowing nothing else about them, I'd be tempted towards the first one simply because the 5 speed has a better record of reliability than the auto although I think with regular maintenance, either will suit you well. Resale value when you're done with it will probably be better too... I'd pay more for a 5 speed truck with no options and high miles than an auto with worn out power everything.

 

[Grumpaw]

What...have I done?

Ya done this.....

 

[Dirtman]

Ranger automatics have never been great for reliability. BUT there are ways to fix that for under 100 bucks. Add an aftermarket cooler, put a drain plug in the pan, and in this one circumstance ignore the factory maintenance schedule. Change out the "pan" fluid every other oil change. (3.5 - 4 quarts). Drop the pan and change the filter every 4th oil change and your transmission will last forever if you don't beat on it.

I wanted a 5 speed manual when i bought my truck new but the manual cost more so i got the auto.

 

[JohnnyO]

I would say rust issues...

Check core support and mounts... cab mounts... bed support rails.... spring hangers.... and have a good look at the bottom of the doors.

Rust on the bottoms of the doors and tailgate, lower rear cab corners.