My biggest complaint with EFI is the soggy throttle response and drive by wire is even worse. If I move the throttle on my carbureted Ranger or Mustang 1/16" it responds instantly and if I spike the throttle the tires smoke. Carbureted vehicles can be efficient, my 351/C4 Ranger averaged 16mpg all last summer even with me playing with the tune. My Mustang does even better, a few years ago I drove 2 hours at 75mph to New England Dragway, made 8 high 13 second passes down the track, drove 2 hours back home and then 3 days back and forth to work-and got 18 mpg. Both vehicles have Holley 80457 vacuum secondary carbs.
For steady state or limited conditions work, carbs can and do work very well....put up against obd1, in a specific condition...they can even out perform captain cave pig efi....by quite a margin in some cases....
Keeping them that way of course is the issue over 70k..... I know my royalstar is getting on my nerves these days....
But ....
I am absolutely shocked...from of all people...to hear you appear to brand out a carb out performing throttle response.
Sure...a stock tune is exactly that...carb or efi....
But I can for sure say a quality efi on your exact engine....throttle by wire or mechanical...especially with a modern automatic....tuned...like yours is dialed in....will provably respond faster with more power.
It is all tune. And the factory stuff is limited for good reason...and generally comes at a price. Like my current 150 the wife drives is a giant pos.
But very fixable...
Look at the banks pedal monster. Specifically for pedal lag...
The nice thing about efi and drive by wire...you can have an 800 hp daily driver....because when it needs to ..it can sluggishly respond.
But I think you know this...and was making a separate point about specifics.
Recurving dizzy and rejetting carb and changing cam position on our camper special was absolutely necessary due to its sluggish response.
And that sluggish response was an artificial dictation by the government which may get a better number if leaving things alone to the market forces