All valid and tru points Will, I just look at it differently. I like my overly strong winch because I get at least 4000-6000 lbs of pull with the most of my cable still on the spool, thus I still have the most speed, which I appreciate when I just need a little help.
And about the backwards winching. I LUUUUUUUUUUUUUUVV my winch for that as well. "HUH, there is no trees (or space) infront of me...." well, I undo my hitch pin and lug it to the back. Problem solved. It's kickass. I had to do this on my first stuck last sunday! lol
Quad winching is different from truck winching BECAUSE there is A-LOT more force developed. The rigs are heavier, the winches are stronger, etc. I know, obviously the line is bigger, but so are the consequences of a mistake. (eg, where guys hook lines, when my pal from work came to help me retireve Bronco, the 1 line he hooked up (as opposed to me hooking lines up) ended up pulling his bumper off, just and experience (with trucks, not quads) thing i guess) I think what he was
reffering to with the 'most useful tool' bit is there is some ingenious ways to get out when you have a winch and some rigging available to you.
I think he is just being imaginative with the Ranger Hover Truck bit, dreaming, if you will.