Shady,
I agree with you on some points...but if you chart the molecule size of a cheap oil to a quality oil you will see a bell curve form form the cheap oil as opposed to a spike with the good oil.
In other words more of the molecules are of the desired size in the quality oil, this will lead to longer life before critical viscosity shear down exist.
to get the "numbers" up requires a more complete cracking of the base stock which increases the final product cost.
and yes, back in the 70's the sythetics did have the problem of shrinking the seals.. due to the single base stock that was used, that isnt really an issue anymore
my recommendation still stands though, The age of your engine should also be a consideration. A vehicle that has over 8 or 9 years on it might not be a good candidate for moving to synthetic oil.
If you've been using synthetic oil with success then
stick with it, but if you've been using petroleum oil, now might not be the time to switch to synthetics.
Here's the deal. Although it is highly unlikely that the issue will come up, the following scenario is apossibility and has happened in a small percentage of older vehicles. A vehicle with significant age which has been maintained with petroleum oil may have seals and gaskets which are dried and cracked.
However, in some cases, petroleum oil burn-off has left behind enough deposits around these
seals and gaskets that leaks have been plugged.
When such an engine is switched over to a premium synthetic oil with a high quality detergency
package, these deposits are cleaned out, thereby exposing those weak seals and gaskets. At that point leaks could occur. Of course, when using a synthetic oil, leaks can be very costly. In some cases, the seal swell properties of the synthetic oil will seal up the leaks, but in other cases it will not.
You have to decide whether you are willing to take the chance. If you're engine runs fairly well and has been adequately maintained, a good synthetic oil could do wonders for performance and fuel mileage in such a vehicle, but the potential leaks must not be overlooked and it doesnt take a whole lot of sludge or varnish entering the filter at once to clog up 10 or 20 micron pore size to the point were the filter starts bypassing
but caveat emptor, I just stated my opinion
Cheers'
Av