all im saying is that all terrains dont clean out very well. i have the same set on my truck and everytime i hit a little bit of mud n water, it slides all over the place.
yea everyone agrees bfg a/ts suck in the mud..
i heard something once, that with snow tires, you WANT a bit of snow packed in the tires, because it helps pull you along, like the snow in the tire wll stick to the snow on the road. this would make sense, cuz as CopyKat says, after 50% tread wear on the bfg ats, they suck in the snow, most likely because they are fully packing with snow, and self clean like shit... at like 75-100% there is 25-50% of the tread not packed with snow, so they do good.
right now im running on three 75% tread 33" bfg ats, and one 50% procomp mt (right rear, sidewall gouge on the 4th bfg at).. i also have a no-slip locker in the rear, but i did better in the snow last year with 75%+ pro comp m/ts and an open diff in the snow.. (last year i had blown front spider gears, right now i have 2 broken axle shafts int he front, so i drive in the snow 2wd constantly--because im too lazy to fix shit in the cold)
so anyways, im undecided on the bfg a/ts. i got them for $450 brand new, on rims.. so it was a deal i couldnt pass up. i probably wouldnt buy them retail.