you can never have too much gear!!!...lol...it sure depend on the application.... and 170 against 220 ft-lbs of torque must do a difference....plus my intake, ignition and header are not pretty good for low end torque.....
4.0l sound like an idear...but can't afford that either...what will help my 2.9l for low end torque?
It isn't only the torque of the 4.0 but how low an rpm you start getting it.
the 2.9 is damn near worthless before 2000rpm
the 4.0 is making 170ft/lb by the time you hit 1250rpm
200ft/lb by 1400-ish and it continues making 200ftlb to over 4000rpm
At no point above 1250rpm does it make less than 170ft/lb
(what a 2.9 can do peak) until it hits the rev limiter.
It's still not low enough in many cases, the only think I'm not looking forward to with my 4.0 and M5OD swap is the taller 1st gear.
the 4.0 makes enough torque down low that if you are switching
to one from a 2.9 you'll never miss the difference in transmission
gearing.
In my specific case I'm running what many would consider
"small" tires, if you are running bigger tires
you can run the wide ratio gears if you REALLY want to.
I just don't like the on-highway performance when towing
or heavily loaded.
That wider 3-4 jump when climbing a steep hill is a really pain.
AD