i just went through this process with my wife's car last week. i went with 'just tires'. she has the same size tires you're lookin for. i got her some kelly's for $557, mounted and balanced, 50K warranty and lifetime mounting and balancing. they had cheaper ones, but they had no warranty and no lifetime mounting/balancing. plus, they have financing that's interest free for 6 months
yeah, you can pay less at a small time local mechanic shop, but then add on how many times you get them rotated and balanced for the life of the tire. you may save $100-200 on the tires, but you'll pay way more than that to have them rotated and balanced for the time that you own the tires.
plus, say my wife and i are in pittsburgh and we have a problem with a tire, we can take it to any just tires and they'll have our warranty info and can fix it for free or replace the tire for free.
yeah, you can pay less at a small time local mechanic shop, but then add on how many times you get them rotated and balanced for the life of the tire. you may save $100-200 on the tires, but you'll pay way more than that to have them rotated and balanced for the time that you own the tires.
plus, say my wife and i are in pittsburgh and we have a problem with a tire, we can take it to any just tires and they'll have our warranty info and can fix it for free or replace the tire for free.