Carlsbad--is Smokey's Speed and Machine in Oceanside still in business?
Anyway, before you do anything do a compression check. If the cylinders are all reading 130-150 then your valves are sealing fine. A valve job isn't a common repair anymore. A burned exhaust valve might occasionally show up as surging, and that once seat might need grinding, but not a whole valve job.
You need to get a new set of Most People. Most People know jack shit. Ticking and clicking are not valve job issues. They are probably stuck lifter issues, or worn rocker issues. Valve job issues are sealing issues. Buy a gauge from Harbor Freight, which I think has a store in Carlsbad, and check the sealing. Then if it shows good sealing, get ready for some wrenching to get those valve covers off. If the lifters turn out to be stuck the heads will have to come off to fetch them out of there.
It sounds like the oil is warming, getting thin and then trouble begins. I spent 11 hours hand planing today and don't have much sense left, but I'll think about what it could be.