Maybe to some thats what matters jim, But to others the compromise can go either way, especially if they tend to drive slower, easier, and arent worried about gas or power, or have future plans etc. Remember not all 31's weigh and handle the same, and where stopping becomes slightly more difficult its not effected enough to negate the extra tire patch he'll have assisting his stop. (least thats the way i see it.) As far as his power, he can regear the truck if it doesnt have the gears right now, and it will be alright.
There is positives and negatives all day long. All you can do is weigh the options and make the choice you think is best.