Will a manual trans from a 2009 4.0 work with my 88 2.9L with the FM146?

[Aidan_1988_xlt]

So I recently acquired a 1988 xlt 2.9 that was originally auto that the guy before me swapped to the fm146 and I believe it’s going bad. He put a clutch and slave in it, (doesn’t seem like he did flywheel though) and I have a grinding noise in all gears except 4th and it also does it idling in neutral but goes away when I push the clutch down. From the research I’ve done so far on this website it seems like the ball bearings inside are likely worn and I know that the reason it doesn’t do it in 4th is because it’s the 1:1 ratio. I’ve also learned I can swap in a M5OD-R1from a 90s-2000s ranger and it’ll bolt up to my 2.9 as they use the same block as the 4.0 OHV. I have a buddy with a manual trans from his ‘09 4x4 4.0 SOHC and I know those ones seemed to use the M5OD-R1HD, so I’m wondering would that trans work with my 2.9 if I want to swap it? Or do I need to use the M5OD-R1
from the 4.0 OHV? I am a third year diesel truck mechanic and know my way around transmissions and have done several clutches and input shafts on freightliners and Mack’s and I’ve done a clutch in my 07 2.3L 2wd Ranger so I’m not completely opposed to getting a kit to rebuild the current FM146 that’s in my 88 now, but I’ve never done a trans rebuild and it does seem a bit daunting and whereas the M5OD-R1 is more reliable I’d feel it would be better to swap it. I’m sure there’s some info on this question already on here but I couldn’t exactly find the answer but I’m sure I could if I looked harder I could find one but wanted to make this post to see what more info/discussion I could drum up. Any advice is appreciated, thank you.

 

[alwaysFlOoReD]

I've read that you can, but have to use the pp, clutch and starter too. But i don't know for sure...

 

[85_Ranger4x4]

Clutch part of the swap looks straightforward

Ford 2.9 Converted To 4.0 Clutch - The Ranger Station

A Ford 2.9 Converted To 4.0 Clutch increases your clutch from an 8-7/8" clutch to a larger and stronger 10" clutch to handle larger tires.

www.therangerstation.com

Stay 2.9/4.0 for a donor and you should be good. I don't know about transmission length, you may run into driveshaft issues.

 

[Aidan_1988_xlt]

Yeah I would definitely upgrade the clutch as well and what not, I also have the manual transfer case so along with the length I’d also have to figure out how to mount the shifter linkage, I’ve also read that the flywheel for the 4.0 would be 8 bolt rather that 6 bolt but I could use an earlier model 4.0 that apparently is 6 bolt but I’d have to check

 

[lil_Blue_Ford]

Yeah, earlier 4.0 had a 6 bolt crank. It changed to 8 bolt for the OHV somewhere around 97/98 I believe. 2.9 had a matching 6 bolt pattern to the early 4.0

 

[85_Ranger4x4]

I don't know anything about the FM since you a diesel tech the M5OD is kind of a fun transmission to rebuild if you want to throw bearings/syncros in it.