Warning, long reply inbound...
Any chance you have a particular brand to recommend? I was looking on Amazon (they are all either made in China or don’t say where) and I got rather concerned by multiple people saying they had lugs strip out, the spacers cracking when the lugs were tightened, or the thing flying off going down the road. I realize there could be some user error, but it’s still concerning. Then when you think about it, most of them for a 1.5” thick spacer are only a shade over $20 each and include a set of lug nuts for mounting it. That seems a tad cheap for something quality. The EBay ones are cheaper, but nothing with reviews.
I do not. The ones I've purchased and used came from Amazon and most likely made in China. I read similar reviews, attributed most of them to installer and user error. That said, there are some on there where the reviews make it glaringly obvious that it is just a bad product.
I've run two "sets" of Amazon spacers between three different vehicles. I can't say that I haven't had a problem, but I can say that problem was not caused by the spacer. The first set was 2" spacers that I ran for a bit on the rear axle of my F-100, that generation had a narrow rear track width. The next "set" was the 1" front and 1.5" rear that I've used on two Rangers, set in quotes because it's actually two sets used together.
The F-100 is the one where I had a problem, but it was not caused by the spacer. It was installer error and neglect, AKA my fault. You see that old truck had a hard life before I got it. The drums on the rear axle actually had some oblonging of the stud holes, but it was slight and had never been an issue with the steel wheels. In addition to being oblonged, they had a slight protruding edge around one side of the hole. I ignored that when I shouldn't have. I recall even making mental note of it when I installed the spacers and wheels, but didn't do anything about it because it had always been there and never been an issue. Well aluminum is softer than steel. Where the steel wheel had clamped and held tight, the softer aluminum material seated further over several miles and allowed the lug nuts to loosen. This guy right here never pulled the wheel off and rechecked the spacers. Few hundred miles later I started hearing a rattle while driving down the road, couldn't locate it. Eventually decided it was one of those things I'd find it and fix it when it breaks. It's an old truck, it sat in dad's yard for over a decade, it's got rattles and bound to develop a few new ones right. Well I definitely found what needed to be fixed when the wheel, spacer attached, left the chat. Lugs holding the wheel to the spacer were tight, no damage what so ever to the wheel. Looking at drum face and spacer, you could see where the raised edges had worked into the aluminum and allowed the it to start shifting. If I'd even once pulled the wheel and checked the spacer lugs, I likely wouldn;t have had a problem. I fully believe that if I had installed an aluminum wheel, instead of steel wheel and spacer, I'd have had the exact same problem. Primary difference being that I probably would have cought it before it actually failed.
The ones on the Ranger have a fair bit more miles on them. I can't say how many miles dad put on the spacers I'm currently running while we had the Explorer wheels on his truck, but no problem then. I've had them on my Ranger with the stock wheels for a few tanks of gas, so a few hundred miles, with no issue. At some point after installing on both Rangers the wheels were pulled back off and the spacers were still tight.
I'll also admit that torque may have been a contributing factor in the different experiences between the trucks. I actually put a torque wrench on the Ranger spacers may be a contributing factor. I probably just used the 4-way lug wrench on the F-100, but I can actually apply more torque with it than the torque wrench and just using the 4 way has never been an issue with wheel installs in the past. Having even torque can be just as important as being tight enough, and having that torque wrench clicks means that it has definitely reach torque rather than just hoping that it has. I'm still convinced that the largest contributing factor to the failure on the F-100 was the wear on the drum face around the stud holes, raised edges around the holes prevented the spacer from seating properly, then the softer aluminum allowed it to conform and loosen up the lug nuts.
Summit Racing has a set, doesn’t say where they are made, but solid reviews. And they are $154 a pair. At $77 each, that should pay for some quality. Maybe. My pockets currently aren’t that deep.
Could be better, could be the exact same thing in a different box. Before buying I went in search of a better option than the eBay specials. Searched up what people reviewed as being good outside of amazon/ebay. Honestly, the majority of what I found looked like the same spacer with a different label on the box, and the webpages didn't install any better opinion of the product/seller than the Amazon/eBay listings did. The few that did appear better put the price well beyond what I could stomach to pay. Spacers were never intended to be a perminent solution where I used them.
On the F-100 the spacers were installed to determine if I wanted to acquire and install a wider rear axle. I most definitely do and it was worth the $40 to make that determination.
For the Ranger it was intended to help decide on fitment and to make the 18" Explorer wheels usable until I could get spend on aftermarket wheels. Again, worth the expense. I just didn't both to remove them when I switched from the Explorers back to the stock wheels. Once we get a solution to the control arm problem it'll be going back down and the Explorer wheels will go back on until I get the aftermarkets.
As a side note to the original poster, I’m trying to fit 18x8” Explorer rims on my Ranger which to achieve the same position on the truck as the 15x7” Ranger rims requires a 1.5” spacer. The Explorer rims I’m using have a much deeper back set, so despite a spacer, I’m really just regaining stock position, which shouldn’t substantially affect wheel bearing life.
Are you trying to achieve the same outside edge position or the same center line position? If you want the face of the wheel to sit in the same spot, you probably want a 1" spacer. If you want the center line in the same spot, the 1.5" might be about right.
This link can help visualize offsets and spacer sizes.
https://jr-wheels.com/et-calculator
stock vs Ex 18x8 w/ 1" spacer
stock vs Ex 18x8 w/ ~1.5" spacer
Actually a 32mm spacer would have the center lines of the wheels match, that converts to about 1.25 inch.
A 20mm spacer would make the faces match, that converts to about to 3/4 inch, but may be too thin for a bolt on spacer. They do sell them, but would probably require trimming the wheel studs.